Men and women obviously have a very different standards for physical ability. They have different teams, different sports, and even different requirements. This has been shown in many different situations. It allows for each gender to excel in their own way. However, there is a group in the House of Representatives pushing to change that. The Equality Act was introduced last month and it has stirred up some major controversy as it will allow transgender athletes to compete in their gender of choice and the opposing side brings up male and female physical differences as well as the religious consequences that this Act would administer.
The endorsing side states that since sports have such positive impacts on a person, both physically and mentally, transgender athletes should not be denied the experience. They push for equal access both on and off the field. However, the opposition is holding to their side, saying that fundamentally, just because one identifies as a different gender, that does not change their physical ability. Therefore, it hinders the fairness of the sports. In fact it is deemed a threat, especially to women’s sports. There have been countless cases of transgender women who, were if to compete in a men’s sport would fall inadequate, however once they decide to compete at a women’s level, they dominate the competition because of the higher levels of testosterone still left in their body. This is the major argument many people have with the bill. It has nothing to do about their personal views as much as the biological component. To put the argument at its most basic: a man can decide to be female, take hormones if required by whatever sporting organization is concerned, win everything in sight and perhaps earn a small fortune, and then reverse his decision and go back to making babies if he so desires. It’s insane and it’s cheating. I am happy to address a transgender woman in whatever form she prefers, but I would not be happy to compete against her. It would not be fair (Martina Navratilova). A professional tennis player Martina Navratilova, is also a lesbian and has experience with the LGBT community highly disagrees with the idea of letting transgender people into the category of sport they choose.
When looked at from a religious standpoint, this is an issue the church is facing as well. With the LGBT community gaining more and more rights, the religious leaders are struggling to represent both the church and the community fairly. In the article, Stranger at the Gate, Mel White explains the trials a person of the LGBT community faces as well as the view point of the opposing leaders. These articles both tie together because they are trying to find a common ground between the wants/needs of the LGBT community and the morals/views of the church.
This is an issues that is incredibly prevalent today, and both parties need to come together and find a place to meet in the middle. Doing so, would help solve situations like the Equality Bill and create peace instead of a major divide.